home Journal club Starting a new series – “Microbiome Wishing” for papers I wish had a microbiome component

Starting a new series – “Microbiome Wishing” for papers I wish had a microbiome component

Just saw the abstract of this paper: The effects of climbing vegetation on the local microclimate, thermal performance, and air infiltration of four building facade orientations that was published 3/19 in Building and Environment.  Authors are Irina Susorova, Parham Azimi and Brent Stephens.  I am intrigued from reading the abstract (I don’t have access to the whole paper).  The abstract is pasted below and I have highlighted a few  parts.


The use of climbing plants and other vegetation types as part of building enclosures has been shown to improve facade thermal performance under certain conditions, although detailed measurements of the impacts of plants on wall shading and local environmental conditions under multiple orientations in real buildings are currently lacking. Therefore, this article presents results from a series of experiments conducted on bare and ivy-covered sections of four pairs of walls of different orientations on existing university buildings during summer conditions in Chicago, IL USA. Over a period of nine days the research team monitored how existing plant layers impacted facade exterior surface temperatures, heat flux through the walls, localized outdoor air temperatures, relative humidity, absolute humidity, and air velocity immediately adjacent to the facades. Changes in nearby air temperatures and air velocity were also used to estimate the impact of the vegetation layer on air infiltration under hypothetical airtightness scenarios. The experimental results demonstrated that the ivy layers reduced exterior surface temperatures by an average of 0.7°C across all facades (12.6°C hourly maximum), depending on orientation and time of day. The ivy layers were estimated to yield a 10% reduction in heat flux through the opaque walls on average for the duration of the experiment, although again varying by orientation and time of day. These findings are consistent with other recent studies. The plant layers also reduced outdoor air temperatures immediately adjacent to the facades by 0.8-2.1°C, on average and varying with facade orientation. Relative humidity was higher inside the vegetation layers, but absolute humidity was actually not affected. Finally, the plant layers were also shown to lead to reductions in wind speeds immediately adjacent to the facades (averages ranging from 0% to 43%, depending on facade orientation and the presence of nearby obstructions), which when combined with measured differences in adjacent air temperature, were estimated to lead to an average reduction in air infiltration rates per unit wall area of 4-12%. Results herein provide further evidence that ivy walls can lead to small energy savings during summer conditions by solar shading and new evidence that additional energy savings may be achieved by reduced air infiltration rates because of the vegetation.

When I read papers like this, as an obsessed microbial diversity person, my first thought is almost always – “What about the microbes?”  Not sure what could / would be done here to address my question but it seems that this system could be used to ask and answer some questions about how microbiomes are affected by plant layers.  Here’s hoping Brent Stephens is thinking about the same thing, as he has a new grant from the Sloan Foundation to work on some things connected to microbiomes of the built environment.  And he has written a few posts here so maybe I can get him to comment about this paper …

UPDATE 11:39 AM 3/24

Brent Stephens has provided a link to a PDF of a preprint of the paper.

Microbiome Wishing


4 thoughts on “Starting a new series – “Microbiome Wishing” for papers I wish had a microbiome component

  1. I have asked Brent Stephens to send you the paper. After you have read the paper you will see that this was not about microbiology, although I understand from Brent that they did collect some swab samples. I suspect we will see another paper later reporting those results. I wish more microbiology papers collected indoor environment/building science data to inform readers’ interpretations of their microbial analysis results and to help us develop a more comprehensive understanding of the microbiology of the built environment, especially the indoor environment.

    Is it OK to blog/post on microbe.net about papers that are not open access?

    For my part, I would adapt the title from your blog post and write: “Indoor environment/building science wishing: for microbiome of the built environment papers that had more building science.”

    1. Hal

      I think you have completely misinterpreted my post. I did not say this paper was “about microbiology”. I was saying – it sounded really interesting and I wish there were some microbial samples to go with the other work they did.

  2. Glad you came across the paper. Irina Susorova, the lead author, has been exploring heat transfer impacts of ivy walls for a while now. She’s done a nice job of integrating architecture, building science, and plant biophysics in her work.

    These buildings were actually right on Jack Gilbert’s home turf at the University of Chicago, so some swabs could be done pretty easily. We have a few ivy covered building here at IIT as well.

    One thing I’m fascinated with is the idea of the filtration efficiency of the building envelope itself. Rather than doing surface samples it would be
    really cool to devise a way to measure what’s called the ‘penetration factor’ of the envelope, albeit for microbes. I’ve published on the penetration of ambient particles before (Stephens and Siegel 2012), and it turns out this value varies pretty highly from building to building. It would certainly influence airborne microbial communities transporting from indoors to outdoors (the parameter is also size resolved), and ivy layers would probably have an interesting
    impact as well on both biological and non-biological penetration/infiltration.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: